I have 20 girl scouts in my troop. They break down, statistics-wise, this way (to make the story make more sense):
My daughter's school:
10 4th-5th grade girls (a mix, but since they're all in class together I'll count them as one group)
Neighborhood girls:
1 5th grader
3 4th graders
Parish school girls:
3 4th graders
3 5th graders
Ok, and more background, my co-leader's daughter is one of those parish school 5th graders. And I have a pair of sisters, both parish school girls, one 4th and one 5th.
So we went camping. Nineteen girls went (one of the neighbor girls was MIA). I told families to be at the parish parking lot at 4:30 on Friday. Most were there. And others arrived shortly after 4:30. There were forms to sign and money to pay and that takes a minute. I was hoping to leave by 4:45. Camp is 1 hour and 10 minutes away.
At 4:45 I had girls situated. My co-leader and her daughter were coming Saturday at lunchtime, and so I knew I needed spots for 18 girls...it was a tight fit and we only had 15 by 4:45. Parents started to trail away and we were distributing permission slips to the drivers when the two sisters' car pulls up. These two, they don't talk to me. It's odd. They are very attached to my co-leader, the older one being her daughter's best friend. But at meetings other girls interact with me and they don't. In fact, they don't interact really at all. It's something to reflect on post-camping because they probably weren't ready for this kind of trip.
But they pull up and each of them has a sleeping bag. And between them they have a huge plastic bag from Target. Seriously. That's how they packed. I try to be accommodating. But really?
So I stuff them in Miss Bridget's car (teacher from my girls' school, girls LOVE her) and I swear on a stack that I was putting one foot in my car, getting ready to pull away, when up drives the last girl with her mom. Cookie mom and daughter. Actually, to be most fair, the woman I refer to as "Cookie Mom" is really "Cookie Grandma" and I have misled you all for 2 years. It makes it even worse though, because the mom is Cookie's daughter-in-law (or ex? or never married? who knows?) and seethes with rage about Cookie's over-involvement with her kids. Caught in a hard place. Let me tell ya.
And I'm angry that she's there. I'm seething because this means even tighter squeeze; she hasn't been to any meetings all year until the one right before camping and cookie sales; I have a hard time separating my anger towards the adults in her life from my benign impression of her herself. And I know that, and so I take a deep breath and act nice. I do. I put her in my car and find room for all her stuff and away we go.
We stay in a lodge, of course, heat, bathrooms, kitchen, the works. Mattresses on the floor, everybody has her own space, and there's a room for leaders with cots. Whee. Friday night is fine. But after lights-out, Cookie girl and the two sisters won't quiet down. And won't quiet down. And flash their flashlights around. And whatever. It's all first-night-at-camp stuff and at 11, things seem quiet.
In the morning, I hear from one of my responsible girls that at midnight, those three got up and ran around shining lights in folks' eyes. I tell her she should have come and told me, but I don't do anything because, again, first night at camp. My early birds are up by 6:00 and that's punishment enough for night owls, right?
But then.
They turn into total bitches. There, I said it. Those three--the two sisters with the target bag of crap, and cookie girl. Some highlights:
*I realize they, and others, have put leftover brown-bag dinner into their cubbies. I tell folks about mice and girls immediately move things to the mostly empty fridge in the kitchen. No big thing. Except later I catch those three eating in the cubby room, so they didn't put things in the fridge. I reiterate.
*They run around, jump on other girls' beds, etc.
*They hide Eliza's stuffed animal and then make fun of her. Before I can intervene, one of the girls from Sophia's school comes to talk to me and starts to cry because they've been snitchy-cat mean to her. And that's it, you know? So I yell at Cookie Girl, who is obviously the ringleader. She's running around the room at the time, jumping around and stirring folks up. I can see the neighbor girls and the girls from Sophia's school (the "montessori girls") getting annoyed and angry. And I let Cookie Girl have it.
I taught middle school and I know how to be scary. And that's what I did. Dead. Silence. I have never yelled at girls in my troop, ever. To be heard, I mean, sure, and I've been stern on the archery range, but never raised my voice to intimidate. And I did. It made an impression.
Cookie girl went over to her mattress and moped. Her friends joined her and gave me dirty looks from their corner. I left the room, coming back in a few minutes later with my coat and boots on. I invited whichever girls wanted to go out in the snow. About half the girls came with me (obviously not those three) and we had a GREAT time in the snow. Tried to sled and that didn't work out with our makeshift sleds, but they rolled down the hill and we looked at animal tracks and threw snowballs and had a nice time. Came back in and Bridget cornered me in the kitchen.
*Cookie and her friends had raided the fridge. Taken all the apples. Did things like take a bite out of each one and then hide them in their sleeping bags. They had then sat on their mattresses all sullen and separate from the rest of the girls, who were playing bananagrams and uno and playing with craft supplies.
So I went over to their corner and didn't raise my voice this time. I pointed out that this wasn't a sleepover, this wasn't their house, and they were to adopt a generous and helpful attitude immediately or they would never camp with me again. And I went to the kitchen to wait to see what would happen. One of their hangers-on, a girl who has been in my troop since kindergarten and was kind of hanging with them but kind of not, came over to me and apologized. I talked to her about choosing friends wisely and that was all. She chose the better part. The other three sat on their beds. They almost skipped lunch, coming in at the very end and finding not much to choose from--just salad, really, was left, and tortillas and ham. They ate at their own table, shooting me dirty looks.
Several times between yelling and when my coleader arrived I lamented all this to Bridget. I just couldn't believe it--I have never had behavior problems in my troop. Yes, girls are loud, yes, occasionally there are personality conflicts. But never like this.
My co-leader arrived and I filled her in on the details. She took all the parish school girls, except one who had never been a part of any of it, on a LOOOOOOONG hike. When they came back, they were new girls.
But while they were gone, I violated their civil rights and went through their stuff. Found all their food. Threw the junk away, put the lunch boxes in the fridge. Didn't tell them. Didn't have anything to say, really, the rest of the weekend about the beginning of the trip.
I found myself, during their hike, really enjoying the remaining 13 girls as they finger-knitted and drew in their journals and played at the craft table. I debated in my head what to do in the future. I love my coleader and I don't want to split down school lines. On the other hand, I think they probably won't be long in my troop. But on yet the other hand, the three of them have huge emotional needs and could really find a respite in scouting if we did it right. Girl scouting is empowering (at least the way I do it, at least the way I try to do it) and they could use some real empowering. They are the least mature of all the girls in the troop, and at the same time they are the ones I would say are old before their time. Rough. But I'm just not sure I'm the person to give them what they need. I don't mean that I wouldn't want to. I mean that I am no counselor. My coleader and I are so well balanced that way--she is all the touchy-feely on their level feel better stuff, and I'm the one who takes all the classes so we can do what we want to do. And I teach them stuff they don't learn anywhere else. It's really good. Except when my co-leader isn't there on Friday night of a camping trip.
So I'm thinking about this. I've been thinking all week, actually. I'm troubled by it. By them. By my desire to balance the good with the bad, to balance 17 girls who are better supported and are in girl scouts to have fun and learn stuff, against 3 girls who maybe need scouting even more....but probably won't stay because it is another thing that they will become too cynical about too soon.
And I'm probably over-thinking it. They were terrible to the other girls on this trip and I don't think they should be allowed to go next time. Or?
See? I'm conflicted. I hate that. So I'm off to Leo's 2 year doctor appointment and more later.