Seriously. I should start a blog dedicated to my girl scout experiences and entitle it "Bridgett Doesn't Care What You Think, This is her Girl Scout Troop".
I have frustrations with the mother ship that are well known. But I stay because GS provides such good cheap ways for girls to do things they wouldn't be able to do or learn in school, at home, or on the playground. Archery, different scout-centric field trips, camping, canoeing, and so forth. I have a high tolerance for paperwork and adult education and my co-leader and I complement each other well.
And over the years we have grown, to the largest number this year at 20 girls. We must be doing something right.
Cookies can be irritating and I have had my fair share--no, more than my fair share--of parents who are just nutty. But I stick with it because of
posts like this.
And as Ann often says, where the tires hit the pavement, things seem to be going ok. I'm the buffer between council and my troop, but on my troop level, sure, there's drama, but it's ok.
Part of my drama is with the cookie family. You remember: Grandma bought 1000 boxes of cookies and then spent probably a year sitting outside a shoe store hawking them. Bizarre. The girl in my troop I've called by many names but here I'll call her Violet because I haven't used that pseudonym yet. Violet goes to the parish school, which I'll call St. Catherine of Siena, along with my co-leader's daughter, the two sisters who have dropped out of my troop, Ursula who has dropped out of my troop, and Jackie, who is still in my troop. I have lost other girls from the parish school along the way. It wasn't until yesterday that I started to realize maybe there was a pattern.
I know a mom, Carol, who is involved with the new brownie troop at Siena. Her daughter was in my troop very briefly, but was really too young and it just didn't seem to fit her very well. Her leaving was actually one of the catalysts that got this daisy/brownie troop organized, and I was all for that. I like to see a sustainable set of troops at a school so it becomes one of the things they do, a normal thing, not out of the ordinary. Siena hadn't really had a troop in years until I came along.
Once upon a time, I started my troop at my parish. I was homeschooling Sophia and so we didn't have a school. Yes, 4 of the 7 girls were from Siena, but I listed us as a church-based group. Over time, the ratio changed. Now, out of the 17 active scouts in my troop, only 3 of them attend Siena. Ten of them go to Sophia's school, and the other 4 live on my street.
But this was a gradual shift.
Sometime between our first year listed as my church's troop, to this year, the neighborhood started designating us as AT Siena (note: Siena is a consolidated school made up of several parishes--so there is a difference saying the church vs. the school). I never walk into Siena. We don't meet there. And we are less and less connected all the time.
Once I was the troop organizer at Sophia's school, and established the brownies and daisies, I debated just swinging over and making our troop based at our school. The problem is that it's in a different neighborhood designation, and that means we'd have to drop our troop number and close our checking account and start over. So I let it slide, really, because it didn't matter where we were based, right?
Well, now that there's this daisy/brownie troop there, it kind of does matter. Suddenly we were lumped in with them for April Showers, and I've already gone over how frustrating that was. And that really isn't that big of a deal, sure, it's only once a year, but then I had this conversation at pick-up time at school.
Carol babysits a kid at Sophia's school, so I see her every afternoon. And we're friendly enough even though I know she has probably had some things to say about me in the past. That street runs both ways, frankly. I also know she's friends with Violet's mom. And I was trying to see what Violet's plans were for the rest of the year (were we to expect her on the camping trip in May?) and for next year.
The brownie/daisy troop will, next year, be a junior/brownie/daisy troop. I have no idea how they will balance this, although this mom says they have lots of adult volunteers so that may be fine. And if they have one leader, like me, with a high tolerance for paperwork, then one troop makes sense. There are schools in the area who have one troop and break out into patrols, more like a boy scout model.
So, talking with her, she says that since Violet's little sister is a daisy in their troop this year, and since next year they'll have juniors, they've invited Violet to join them. I told Carol this sounded good--Violet didn't do anything this year, really, and so juniors would be practically new for her next year. I asked her if there was a problem between Violet's mother/grandmother and my troop set-up, because she hadn't made but one meeting, but came to both big field trips. And then she told me.
Grandma feels like we don't communicate with her. She's angry because Violet doesn't get to do things with the money SHE raised by selling cookies. I've heard this song and dance before and it rolls off my back. Grandma doesn't know when meetings happen and doesn't get notes. Mom thinks we don't approve of her because she's a single mom (umm, so is my coleader) and therefore we have cut her out of the loop. Mom works evenings and Sundays (my meeting day) and Grandma is, well, nutty.
I nod through all of this. It doesn't upset me. I ask Carol what I might do better--does Violet's mom have email, for instance? I mention that Sunday is our meeting day and she says that this is probably the problem, frankly. Sunday afternoons are busy and they forget things. Well, that's a shame, because Sunday meetings were a huge relief to so many of my parents that we're not changing it. We can't meet after school (I'm saying this out loud to her) because my coleader doesn't get home until 5:30, and our girls come from so many different schools. And we didn't want to pick one evening because so many evenings are already busy.
"Oh, that's another thing," Carol stops me. "A lot of people at Siena don't like that you have girls from other schools in your troop. Girls at Siena just aren't comfortable with outside girls being in the troop. I know that my daughter, I mean, your troop was great, but she wasn't comfortable because of all your outside girls."
"I understand that feeling," I TOTALLY LIE. I think the school-based diversity in my troop is one of its strengths. "That's just the way my troop evolved."
"I know," Carol continues. "And I think because you were the top leader at Siena, having the older girls, but so many outsiders, it kind of stifled the growth of girl scouts at Siena over all. Your troop, and you and your coleader, are seen as kind of separate, as not open to new girls, not meeting people halfway, not really being attached to Siena and not friendly."
Smack. It's been a week of smacking Bridgett. Wow.
"Really?" I ask her.
"Yeah. It wasn't until me and the other moms decided to do our own thing and not depend on you anymore that girl scouts really even got a footing at Siena. And now our girls can be in a troop with girls from Siena and not from all over the neighborhood and feel comfortable and do things together. And now we have a good girl scout program set up."
Ok.
Granted, I'm not going to hold anyone's hand anymore because these girls are in 4th and 5th grade and they need to figure out how to get to meetings or talk to me about it. And my coleader and I have stopped bending over backwards for families who can't get their acts together. I will totally cop to that. Looking back, we have lost quite a few Siena girls: Violet, Ursula, the two sisters--those were this year alone. And over the years, I've lost Jenny, Katie, Paula Jean, Olga. But for some reason my coleader has stayed with me, and then there's Jackie, too. What's going on at Siena that doesn't match what's going on in my troop? Where is the disconnect?
I thanked Carol for her honesty and she said that the leaders at Siena were interested in drawing ALL the Siena girls into their troop--basically, take the few that were left with me and bring them into their fold. "Who else goes to Siena and is in your troop, anyway?"
"Well, there's my coleader's daughter, and I assume she isn't going to leave, and one of my girls is transferring there next year. But they're going to be cadettes, and that seems pretty far-fetched to have two cadettes with all those young girls. And there's Jackie--"
"Oh, Jackie and Violet HATE each other," she shakes her head.
"Yeah, I got that impression at our camping trip in Januar. Violet and her friends kind of morphed into mean girls--"
"Yeah, Violet's mom knows. There's been some problems in the classroom. Siena doesn't have a bullying problem, but that class really, wow."
"I can see that," I nod.
"So you can keep Jackie and the older girls but we'll go ahead and take over and be the Siena troop."
Well then.
I ask again: what is going on at Siena that is so opposed to my set up? Is it that I'm just too montessori-based, or is it some kind of frustration or anger that I didn't send Sophia the Dyslexic to the traditional parish school that would have crushed her? And perhaps made her into a xenophobe with an underdog complex? I'm not impressed.
Telling this whole story to my coleader, she said we should just wash our hands of the troop connection to Siena. So now my task is to find out how and be as diplomatic as I can. We SHOULDN'T be a Siena troop. There's nothing Siena about us, frankly. We have girls from there, but we have one girl from a magnet school and one from a private school in Clayton. We're not based THERE either. Logically, we should switch to Sophia's school. But maybe we don't have to be school based at all. Seriously. Do we really need to? There are homeschool troops. We could be a neighborhood troop. Because I think I'm done with this snitchy-cat BS coming from Siena.
So there's my rant for today. Now I need to go do dishes and work in the yard briefly in the (again) cold. Feed Leo some lunch and change the sheets on the beds. Yay me.
UPDATE: Called council. There's a form. I fill it out and we'll be based at Sophia's school in that neighborhood and life is easy again and Siena folks can stop worrying about me.